Heart Temptations

This infographic from Life Over Coffee captures the central thesis of James 1:14–15: The true source of temptation is not external but internal.

Across the top of the infographic, we see images of food, money, alcohol, love, and technology—symbolic representations of things that can easily become entangling temptations. But the graphic wisely places all these above a dotted line, representing a visual separation from the heart—the actual source of temptation.

Key Observations

Central Heart Icon labeled “Desires” anchors the graphic, showing that temptation begins with what the heart wants—not what the eyes see. The passage from James 1:14 reminds us: “Each person is tempted when he is lured and enticed by his own desire.” The lure is internal. The bait might be external, but the hook is forged in the desires of the heart. James 1:15 continues: “Then desire when it has conceived gives birth to sin, and sin when it is fully grown brings forth death.” Sin is not a momentary slip—it is a progressive conception that begins with disordered desire, moves toward action, and ends in spiritual death.

Theological Significance

This is a corrective to externalized, behavior-focused approaches to change. It’s easy—and dangerously deceptive—to assume that if we simply avoid the “bad things” (alcohol, money, tech, etc.), we’re righteous. But that’s a gnostic and legalistic understanding of sanctification, not a biblical one. James forces us to see that the external object is not the problem; the heart is. As Jesus said in Mark 7:21–23, “Out of the heart come evil thoughts…”—not from our phones, not from the fridge, not from our bank accounts.

The Error of Amputation Without Heart Transformation

There are indeed times when we must “cut off” the stumbling block (Matthew 5:30), but that act alone is never sufficient. Hebrews 12 tells us to “lay aside every weight and sin.” You can amputate the weight and still retain the sin. If you only amputate but never mortify the heart’s desire, sin simply finds a new outlet.

Case Study: Mable and the Illusion of Change

Mable is a believer who spends significant time on social media. Her friend Marge lovingly confronts her, pointing out how much of her life orbits around platforms like Instagram and Facebook. Mable agrees. She confesses, “I think I’m addicted,” and commits to a social media fast. For a while, she’s offline. But when the fast ends, she’s back—just as deeply entangled as before.

What happened?

Legalism in Disguise

Mable is operating out of a legalistic understanding of sin: “If something tempts you, just separate from it.” This is what some call the “doctrine of separation”—if tech is the problem, cut out tech. But Mable never addressed the true issue: her heart. The real struggle is not social media. The platform simply becomes a vehicle for her craving—control of her image and the illusion of community on her own terms. Her heart is hungry for:

• Approval: through likes and comments.
• Significance: through follower counts and visibility.
• Love and respect: but without vulnerability or risk.
• Control: curating a version of herself that is polished, praised, and never rejected.

Even if she never touched social media again, Mable would find another tool—maybe email lists, group texts, church volunteerism, or flattery—to manufacture approval and curate her image. The idol isn’t the app; it’s her heart.

Application and Gospel Hope

If you’re helping someone like Mable, you must walk them through James’s teaching: “Each person is tempted when he is lured and enticed by his own desire.” You don’t begin with what she’s doing but what she’s loving. Ask:

• What does your heart crave when you’re online?
• What are you afraid would happen if you lost that platform?
• What version of yourself are you protecting?
• Who are you trying to impress, and why?

Then, gently lead her to the cross—not to fast harder, but to worship differently. Jesus is not asking her to cut off social media so she can be pure; He’s calling her to surrender her craving for approval, significance, and control, and find it all in Him. Cutting out temptation without addressing the heart merely delays idolatry; it doesn’t destroy it. You can amputate a habit, but if you don’t mortify the desire behind it, you haven’t repented—you’ve only relocated your sin.

Mable must repent of her desire to be god in her world, rather than worship Him in His.

Find all our graphics here.

Peace,
Rick