0

Your Thoughts Reveal Your Functional Identity

Your Thoughts Reveal Your Functional Identity

Photo: ©pixelshot via Canva.com

Exploring your functional identity during a season of difficulty benefits you in many ways. I’m speaking of your practical life that might conflict with what it means to be a Christian. Wayward hearts and vulnerable souls can easily skew their identities, resulting in the construction of false worship structures, which, when present, can lead to increased hopelessness and difficulty during trials.

In This Series

Deeper Conversations

Caring for a friend amid a trial is complex. Feelings of inadequacy can surface as one searches for the perfect words to ease the weariness of one’s soul. Sympathetic listening is always the ideal starting point, but if soul care is to occur, the conversation must go deeper than superficial discussions. With gentleness and patience, the conversation must lead and encourage them to engage with God to embrace His Sovereign and purposeful work in their lives. God uses all things for their good (Romans 8:28-29), and often, these seasons provide fertile ground to expose idols of the heart and gaps in an individual’s gospel understanding.

Due to our fallen natures, we tend to be blind to the things that move us, which are the catalysts that fuel our engines. Even those who are biblically literate often lack a sound grasp of their hearts’ ruling motives. One may question the wisdom of this line of reasoning during a season of difficulty. For example, how does directing a wife to understand the idols of her heart help when she is reeling from her husband’s recently confessed adultery? This conversation is practically and spiritually profitable from a Christian, gospel-driven perspective.

Suffering wears out the soul, which can be made worse by sin and idolatry (1 Peter 2:11). The purity of your worship directly impacts the health of your soul, and the identification and dismantling of false worship structures (idols of misplaced desires) will help your soul find rest. Heart idols are the fruit of improper thinking, and if this thinking is left unchecked, the conclusions reached amid a season of suffering can lead to further harm by seeking counterfeit solutions. Even amid a life turned upside down, you must remember Christ didn’t come to save you from a bad marriage or a lousy job. False worship structures affect our souls by causing us to lose sight of the gospel’s good news. In essence, we revert to a works-based salvation, as if Christ’s sacrifice isn’t sufficient.

Your greatest need remains Christ for your salvation and your ongoing sanctification. As Paul Tripp said, “The good news of the kingdom is not freedom from hardship, suffering, and loss. It is the news of a Redeemer who has come to rescue me from myself. His rescue produces change that fundamentally alters my response to these inescapable realities.” Humility positions you to receive Christ’s grace (James 4:6). David Powlison states, “Christ powerfully meets people who are aware of their actual need for help. Christ’s forte is our acknowledged need in the face of compulsions from within and pressures from without” (2 Corinthians 12:9-10).

  1. How can you help a friend biblically understand themselves and better respond to their season of suffering?
  2. How can someone navigate the storylines, emotions, and hurt to help their friend see their heart’s tendencies?

One way is to recognize how their worship reflects their identity. Using a person’s self-defined identity as an entryway is often effective, helping them ascertain their purpose in life and gain a more accurate assessment of themselves and their environment (Psalm 139:23). This avenue of inquiry can often bring freshness and clarity to their thinking as they focus on the workings of their hearts, ideally leading them to a renewed dependence on Christ for all things (John 15:5). Asking these kinds of questions can help them find rest for their souls and empower forward-moving, hope-filled progress.

Christian counseling is counseling which exposes our motives—our hearts and our world—in such a way that the authentic gospel is the only possible answer. – David Powlison

Rick's Books on Amazon

A Christian’s True Identity

The Westminster Catechism states that man’s chief purpose is to “Glorify God and enjoy Him forever,” though sin has taken humanity away from this original position and purpose.

Individually, we were created to serve God, but sin confused everything, tangling our hearts with pride, false idols, false securities, and false saviors, all knotted together into one disordered mess from which we cannot free ourselves. Only by grace are we given eyes to see the depth of our complex hearts and two-faced motives, and only by grace do we find a Great Physician committed to untangling our disordered hearts. – Tony Reinke

Hearts are continuously enticed, tempted, and deceived by the lust of the flesh, the lust of the eyes, and the pride of life (1 John 2:16). Hidden and insidious desires always seek to shape lust-filled hearts. You choose things that you perceive as good and desirable, things you think will result in success, comfort, and significance. Over time, these selections metamorphose into your identity.

How do we make an identity out of temptation? By collapsing what you desire with who you are. – Rosario Butterfield

A man may desire to become successful in his career. This desire is okay if he is careful, but if not, he can start placing value on his career. As a result, his career becomes his identity, and his focus turns away from Christ and onto the many opportunities or threats to his career. He has added “career success” to the gospel message. As a result, his joy, or soul health, links to his performance at work, which can manifest many false worship structures. A woman desires to be the perfect mother and starts to define her worth as such. When this happens, her children’s public behavior takes on a self-focused commentary, and she becomes fearful about how their actions reflect her parenting ability. Her joy, or soul health, links to something apart from Christ. Again, she has added “perfect mother” to the gospel message.

False identities can even attach themselves to ministry. If a pastor’s identity shifts away from Christ to being a pastor, his allegiance will become askew. He will analyze trends in church attendance, the reception of his messages, or the divorce rate of couples he counsels and reach unfortunate conclusions about himself. In all these cases, the individual’s thinking turns temporal and their focus inward. Given the wayward tendencies of fallen hearts, the first step you must take daily is to remind yourself of your true identity. During the business of family and work, with all of the entanglements of church and community, you must continue orienting your life to Christ (Colossians 3:11).

If I may speak my own experience, I find that to keep my eye simply upon Christ, as my peace, and my life, is by far the hardest part of my calling. A thousand such surrenders I have made, and a thousand times I have interpretatively retracted them. – John Newton

You can see the well-known pastor and hymnist engaged in the conflict we all face as Christians. You want to do right but find yourself doing the opposite (Romans 7:15). It is the daily call to die to yourself (Matthew 16:24).

Leaders Over Coffee Web Banner

Understanding the Battle

The fight for your identity is the same flesh-spirit battle you face as a Christian (Galatians 5:17). Using the world’s temptations, the enemy aligns with your flesh to shift your identity and, ultimately, your focus away from Christ.

We should be careful at the temptation to minimize our involvement in taking the bait, for the sinner’s rebellious nature finds the forbidden thing more attractive, not because it is inherently attractive, but because it furnishes an opportunity to assert one’s self-will. – John MacArthur

Seeing yourself in the light of truth requires spiritual discernment (Obadiah 1:3) and a firm grasp of the gospel to overcome the indwelling shame, fear, and guilt that reside in your flesh and make it difficult to accept the truth about yourself (John 2:25). The freedom of the gospel only comes when your focus is building up your new identity in Christ and leaving fleshly-inspired identities behind (Philippians 3:13-14). Many Christians never fully reach this point. Their souls are too tender and sensitive from past evil or years of poor care. It is similar to providing care to a burn victim; any attention initially brings pain.

Peeling back the many layers of life’s self-centered solutions is too excruciating to allow a new identity to take root (2 Corinthians 5:17). As a result, they stand firm in who they think they are, defending their self-reliant tendencies and self-righteous ways daily. The enticement is the hidden danger of a false identity; it has no power or legitimacy and requires the self to defend, justify, promote, refine, reinvent, and maintain. It creates a heavy yoke and a propensity towards unbelief (Matthew 11:30). Thus, when helping a hurting friend think correctly and biblically about their identity, the disciple must execute with patience, gentleness, and love.

A Final Word

It is essential to state that a properly aligned, in-Christ identity does not eliminate suffering from your life, but it does create a new type of freedom, as evidenced in the life of Apostle Paul. It is clear that his life was full of hardships
(2 Corinthians 11:23-29), but he was able to respond positively. For instance, despite being in jail, Paul could see gain (Philippians 1:21), but only because his identity was in the gospel; his joy was Christ’s joy. When evil enters your world, it only impacts your temporal life. Your identity in Christ is eternal and remains unchanged, leading you to experience a peace that surpasses your understanding (Philippians 4:7).

To illustrate, I will borrow from Chicken Little’s demise. Some of life’s difficulties and challenges, represented by rocks of varying shapes and sizes, will fall from the sky and disrupt your existence. If your identity is in something other than Christ, each rock will deliver a crushing blow to you, leaving you dazed and confused. If your identity is in Christ, these rocks will no longer have a crippling effect. Although they still have to be dealt with, you can navigate around the obstacle and address the disruption in a much calmer, gospel-centered, liberating way—in a way that reminds you (and others) that you are a living character in God’s wonderful story of redemption.

Call to Action

  1. What does it mean to have an identity in Christ?
  2. What does having an identity in Christ while living in a fallen body look like?
  3. What has a suffering event in your life, whether past or present, revealed about your functional identity in Christ?
  4. Why is disappointment a good reminder of where we stand with God?
  5. What idol has been in your life that created an identity more valuable than your in-Christ identity? Why did it have an appeal? What will be your next step to repentance if you have not already repented?

Need More Help?

  1. If you want to learn more from us, you may search this site for thousands of resources—articles, podcasts, videos, graphics, and more. Please spend time studying the ones that interest you. They are free.
  2. If you want to talk to us, we have private forums for those who support this ministry financially. Please consider supporting us here if you would like to help us keep our resources free.

Mastermind Program Web Ready Banner